Anyone
reading s story A Clean, Well Lighted Place side-by-side with William Faulkners story The
Bear might be struck by a number of similarities and differences, including the
following:
- Both works deal with young people who have a lot to
learn, but Ike McCaslin seems to learn more in The Bear than the young waiter does in A
Clean, Well Lighted Place. - Ike matures more than the young waiter does,
partly because Ike is more willing to learn from persons older than he is. - Both Ike and the young waiter have father figures in their stories (Sam in the case
of Ike; the older waiter in the case of the young waiter), but Ike seems more open to
instruction than the young waiter is. - A bond forms between Ike and Sam
despite their different racial backgrounds, but the young waiter seems far less willing to move
beyond his own narrow, limited perspective. - Ike learns valuable lessons
about humanitys place in the universe, but the young waiter seems far less open to such
learning. - The young waiter seems far more selfish and uncaring than Ike, as
when he says to an old deaf man who lingers too long in the caf© where the waiter works,
"You should have killed yourself last
week."
It is hard to imagine Ike ever being so
callous and cruel.
No comments:
Post a Comment