Saturday, October 9, 2010

Are the crystal glasses and the desert allegorical in Coelho's The Alchemist? Explain.

I don't
think I'd use the word "allegorical" with regard to the crystal glasses or the desert.
I would imagine that "symbol" would be more accurate with the glasses, and the desert
may be more a .

Anis defined as...


...an extended metaphor in which a person, abstract idea, or event stands for itself
and for something else.

With an allegory, there
is also the sense that hearing the story or the narrative provides a lesson or a "moral to
the story."
Because you have identified items, I would
assume that these things might be symbolic (or metaphoric), representing something significant
by which to better understand the story.

In this case, I believe that the
crystal glasses are symbolic. In 's , Santiago (the boy) is ready to give
up his search for his Personal Legend. He has been robbed and he's feeling defeated. So he
promises himself to get a job, save up his money, buy sheep, and return home.


Santiago goes to the crystal merchant and suggests that if he cleans the dirty crystal,
perhaps the man could feed him. The man does not respond, so the boy begins to clean each glass
until it sparkles. Afterward, the man says:

You didn't
have to do any cleaning...The Koran requires me to feed a hungry person.


The boy is puzzled and asks:


Well then, why did you let me do it?

The
merchant replies:

Because the crystal was dirty. And both
you and I needed to cleanse our minds of negative thoughts.


The crystal merchant's take on the situation speaks directly to the boy's difficulty at
this time in his life. The dirty glasses symbolize the boy's inability to look into the future
and see the potential for success. Being without money, food or a place to live has dampened his
spirithas clouded his vision of pursing his dream and his Personal Legend. In cleaning the
glasses, they become beautiful again and draw one's eye. As Santiago spends time in the company
of the crystal merchant, he begins to see the wisdom of moving forwardhis "vision" is
cleansed (as were the glasses) so that his hopes for the future become "crystal clear"
once again, and his mind's eye is drawn to his Personal Legend as the sparkling crystal draws
one's physical vision.

As for the desert, I see this as a metaphor. The
desert seems to represent emptiness and desolation. However, as the
alchemist shows the boy, many things are hidden in the desert. Life is hidden beneath the sand.
The alchemist says to the boy...

Show me where there is
life out in the desert. Only those who can see such signs of life are able to find
treasure.

The boy notes that he does not know how to do
this. The alchemist announces:

Life attracts
life.

Hearing this the boy gives free rein to his horse.
Santiago notes:

I don't know the language of the desert,
but my horse knows the language of life.

And the horse
does, indeed, find a hole. The alchemist puts his hand inside and brings out a snake. It is
disconcerting for the boy, but it shows that what is on the surface is not always what we find
beneath. And while the desert may seem to hold little promise of life, it
has life and allows life to prosperin an unlikely place. And while it may
seem to hold even less promise of treasure, it is a search that will prove fruitful. The desert
is a metaphor: Life is sometimes a desert, holding little promise, but if one looks beneath the
surface, treasure, life, may be hidden out of sight.

No comments:

Post a Comment

How is Joe McCarthy related to the play The Crucible?

When we read its important to know about Senator Joseph McCarthy. Even though he is not a character in the play, his role in histor...