Monday, December 5, 2011

In "Charles" by Shirley Jackson, what is Laurie's relationship with his parents like? How would it be described?

On the
surface, the relationship between Laurie and his parents seems quite typical. When he starts
kindergarten, he starts wearing jeans instead of overalls and this shows how he is becoming more
independent. He begins taking a more active role in who he is. Laurie uses this stage of his
development to try different things. The narrator (mother) notes how he becomes more thoughtless
and insolent when talking with his father. Laurie is testing the limits of what he can and can
not get away with. Laurie tests his parents' and teacher's patience. While this is also a
typical phase that many children go through, it does seem that Laurie goes a bit too far. Laurie
knows this as well. That's why he creates an alter-ego in order to do the things that he knows
are wrong. On the other hand, he also attributes his good deeds with . Note that it is Charles
who acts as the teacher's helper. By acting out, via Charles, Laurie creates a problem in his
relationship with his parents. He uses a lie (not telling them that he is Charles) in order to
tell the truth. 

The relationship between Laurie and his parents is
troublesome because Laurie lies about what he has been doing at school and he is rude to his
parents. On the other hand, Laurie tells them everything he does; he just uses his alter-ego as
a way of disclosing everything. Their relationship would best be described as complicated or
problematic. He tells them everything Charles does but does not tell them that he is Charles.
So, it is an oddof lies and truth. Their relationship is therefore paradoxically healthy but
also problematic. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

How is Joe McCarthy related to the play The Crucible?

When we read its important to know about Senator Joseph McCarthy. Even though he is not a character in the play, his role in histor...