Friday, March 15, 2013

Why Did Brutus Kill Caesar

The previous
answers both link to the theme of 'public good versus personal benefit'.  Brutus kills a friend
for the sake of Rome.  He puts his country's needs before his own. 

Another
theme that  is strongly demonstrated through Brutus is  'lack of self-knowledge'.  Brutus is
manipulated into believing that Caesar will become a tyrant and destroy Rome as a
republic. (Remember that the term republic is not what we define as a 'republic' in modern era -
the Roman republic did not give commoners voting rights for instance.)  


Brutus allows Cassius to be 'his mirror' and to dictate his thoughts and emotions. 
Cassius cleverly flatters Brutus by telling him that Caesar is no better than Brutus, Caesar is
not a god, but Brutus has the admiration and support of the people of Rome.  The Romans are
looking at Brutus to save them from Caesar' tyranny.

If Brutus was more in
touch with his own strengths and weaknesses, he would have identified Cassius as a manipulator. 
He would have been able to question why Cassius hated Caesar so vehemently that he would attempt
to humiliate Caesar to the extent where he compares him to 'a girl'.  Cassius launches a
personal attack on Caesar.  Brutus should have been able to question this since he was a man
with 'grey hair'  (wise) at this stage.  Yet, he does not, he accepts everything Cassius tells
him and joins the conspiracy despite the fact that it troubles him so much that he is unable to
sleep or find peace of mind. 

This reveals that Brutus does not understand
enough about his own weakness, he is unaware of the fact that he is easily manipulated. He does
not realise that he is being used by Cassius to reach a private goal (destroying Caesar out of
envy) rather than acting for the good of Rome.  Shakespeare confirms this notion when Rome is
destroyed after the killing of Caesar.  Both Cassius and Brutus die as well which leaves the
audience with the question as to whether any of this would have taken place if Brutus did not
allow himself to be manipulated by a man (Cassius) who was not thinking about the good of Rome
in the first place.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

How is Joe McCarthy related to the play The Crucible?

When we read its important to know about Senator Joseph McCarthy. Even though he is not a character in the play, his role in histor...